Have you ever been told to “just be yourself” or “be authentic” as a leader? Or maybe you’ve read articles encouraging you to “discover your authentic leadership style”?
The idea of “being authentic” as a leader (and person) is everywhere– books, articles, social media –that the secret to great leadership (and life) is authenticity.
And it sounds great. It feels good.
But here’s the thing: while it sounds attractive, much of what passes for “authentic leadership” advice today (and authenticity in general) can actually be limiting your effectiveness as a leader and holding you back.
In this article, we’ll explore where the popular understanding of authenticity and authentic leadership falls short, why it can lead you astray, and how you should think about leadership instead.
Let’s get to it.
(I should note that there are different versions of authentic leadership – the popular interpretation often presented I’ll address mostly, and later we’ll briefly talk about some of the more “nuanced” versions. )
The Problem with “Just Be Authentic”
Before we get into leadership specifically, let’s review a few key issues with the general “be authentic” mentality that I covered in a previous article.
Authenticity can limit your growth
We’re complex human beings who naturally adapt and change. We’re meant to learn, evolve, and develop new skills.
When you say, “that’s just who I am,” you set a limit on yourself and what you can be. Often, “who we are” is just what we are comfortable with (we’ll dive deeper into that in the piano analogy below). We have a wide range of growth of who we can be as a person, which we limit by sticking with what we are comfortable with right now.
Not everything “authentic” is good
Another issue is the assumption that everything “authentic” to us is automatically positive. But what if some of your authentic tendencies are harmful or are holding you back?
Maybe you’re “naturally” disorganized, conflict-avoidant, or quick to judge. Should you embrace these traits simply because they feel “authentic”? Probably not.
We confuse comfort with authenticity
We tend to gravitate toward what feels familiar and comfortable, then label that as our “authentic self.” But comfortable doesn’t always mean authentic – it just means familiar.
The label trap
One limiting aspect of the authenticity mindset is how we create labels for ourselves – “I’m a neat freak,” “I’m not a details person,” “I’m just not good with public speaking” – and then let those labels dictate what we can and can’t do.
We create these labels based on certain behaviors, then let the labels define us rather than us defining the labels.
The piano analogy
Communication coach Vinh Giang gives a beautiful example with his piano analogy. He says your voice is like a piano with 88 keys, but most people only use, say, 8-10 keys regularly.
When someone claims that speaking in a different pitch isn’t “authentic” for them, Giang pushes back: it’s not inauthentic, it’s just unfamiliar. The entire range is authentically yours – you just haven’t practiced using all of it.
What you call your “natural voice” is actually just your habitual voice. And the most inauthentic thing you can do is to limit yourself to only a small portion of your full range.
Why this matters for leadership
These wrong ideas about authenticity cause real problems for leaders. Many leaders stick to what feels comfortable, calling it “authentic,” when they’re really just limiting how effective they can be.
Great leadership often requires you to stretch beyond your comfort zone, develop new skills, and adapt to different situations. If you’re hiding behind “authenticity” to avoid doing the hard work of growth, you’re not serving your team or your mission effectively.
(For a deeper dive into these topics—

