Why “Leadership” Has Become Meaningless (And What That Costs All of Us)

Sculpture of a head with words like confidence, character, and entrepreneurship on the face.

Leadership is one of the most discussed and researched topics in social sciences. Billions of dollars are spent in the leadership training industry, yet we continue to have so much poor leadership in our organizations and world.

Why is that?

There are numerous factors that affect it, but one of the biggest reasons is this:

The word ‘leadership’ itself has become nearly meaningless.

It gets applied to everything from preschool behavior programs to personal development to tech startup job titles to motivational Instagram posts.

When a word is used for everything, it starts to mean nothing — and when ‘leadership’ means nothing, we end up with fewer people who actually know how to lead.

This isn’t an attack on the idea of leadership. It’s the opposite. Leadership matters too much for it to become a hollowed-out, meaningless word.

In this article, we will dive deep into how leadership has become its own worst buzzword. We will explore the buzzword concept, how leadership became one, what it costs us, and what we can do about it.

“Leadership” Has a Word Problem

Buzzwords are trendy, important-sounding terms people repeat so often that they start to lose any clear, concrete meaning. Even good words with originally good meanings become hollow.

Examples of buzzwords you may have heard include “synergy”, “empowerment,” or “disruption.”

Unfortunately, “leadership” fits that bill.

It has become one of the most overused, diluted, and monetized terms in today’s culture, and it makes sense: it sounds aspirational and prestigious.

It’s hard to know what good leadership is when there’s no clear meaning for the term itself.

Before We Go Further — Here’s What Leadership Actually Is

If one of the biggest problems of leadership today is a lack of a clear definition, it’s probably important for us to find a clear definition that we can use moving forward in this article (and beyond).

This definition is a paraphrase of Peter Northouse’s definition (paraphrased to make it more human and less technical sounding):

Leadership is the process of guiding people toward the accomplishment of a goal through influence.

Or the short version:

Leadership is guiding people somewhere through influence.

Leadership is a process – It’s grounded in principles, but what you do changes based on the need and situation, and working with people and situations is a process.

You are taking people somewhere – If you aren’t taking people somewhere, you are just being a nice (or not so nice) person. You must be going somewhere.

It’s guiding through influence – It’s not based on authority or manipulation or force. People willingly follow. Influence is the trust, respect, and relationship you have with others that causes them to act with and for you.

(To learn more about the definition, read the article here).

This is a good definition because it’s grounded in research, it’s neutral, and it tells what the work is. It defines what leadership is instead of trying to define it by the how.

Leadership is also not management. The simplest way to tell the difference between the two comes from Julie Zhou’s book, The Making of a Manager. To paraphrase:

Leadership is a skill. Management is a position. You don’t need a position to be a leader, but you can’t be a good manager without also being a good leader.

(We dive deeper into this difference in this article here).

I think it’s important to note that not everyone who says “leadership” poorly intends to mislead. Many mean something useful (personal growth, responsibility, self-management), but they rarely define it precisely.

With that definition in hand, let’s look at all the places